Liability · November 2026 · 6 min read

Per-Occurrence Limits Versus Aggregate Limits

One limit caps a single event. The other caps everything the policy will pay across an entire year.

A liability declarations page carries several numbers. Owners read the first one and stop, because the first one is the big reassuring figure. The second one is the ceiling that actually runs out.

What the numbers on the page mean

A commercial liability page typically lists an each occurrence limit, a general aggregate limit, a products and completed operations aggregate, a personal and advertising injury limit, a damage to premises rented to you limit, and a medical expense limit.

Two of those do the structural work.

Each occurrence is the most the policy pays for any one event, no matter how many people were hurt in it.

General aggregate is the most the policy pays for everything, across the whole policy period. Every payment erodes it. When it is exhausted, the policy is finished for that year even if eight months remain on it.

The common structure is a million per occurrence and two million aggregate, which reads as two million of protection and is not.

One point in favor of homeowners liability

Worth naming because it runs against the usual direction of this series.

Homeowners liability generally has no aggregate. It is a per occurrence limit, and it resets for the next occurrence.

Commercial general liability has aggregates. So a homeowners policy with a $500,000 liability limit and no aggregate behaves differently across a bad year than a commercial policy at a million and two million, and not always worse.

None of that fixes the occupancy problem that makes a homeowners policy the wrong contract for a rental. It is worth understanding anyway, because comparing a homeowners limit to a commercial limit is not a comparison of two like numbers.

What counts as one occurrence

Occurrence is a defined term. It typically means an accident, including continuous or repeated exposure to substantially the same general harmful conditions.

That definition is contested constantly, and the outcome moves large amounts of money.

A deck fails during a family reunion and six people are hurt. That is one occurrence. Six claimants share a single per occurrence limit.

A carbon monoxide event affects a family of five. One occurrence. Five claimants, one limit.

Two guests are injured on the same defective stair tread on different weekends. Whether that is one occurrence arising from a single continuous condition or two separate accidents is exactly the kind of question that gets argued, and the answer determines whether one limit applies or two.

The pattern worth noticing is that short-term rentals host groups. A single event at a rental produces multiple claimants far more often than a single event at a residence, which means the per occurrence limit gets divided more often.

Where the defense costs sit

This is the most consequential thing in this article and the least likely to be on anyone’s radar.

On a standard commercial general liability form, defense costs are paid in addition to the limit. The carrier hires and pays the lawyers, and none of that touches the money available to settle.

On some professional liability forms, some program policies, and a number of surplus lines placements, defense costs are inside the limit. These are called eroding or wasting limits, and every dollar spent on defense is a dollar removed from what remains for the claimant.

Take a million dollar limit and a case that runs $340,000 in defense before it resolves. Outside the limit, there is still a million available to settle. Inside the limit, there is $660,000.

Same declarations page number. Different contract. Find out which one you have.

A bad year on a four-property portfolio

An owner runs four cabins on one commercial liability policy at a million per occurrence and two million aggregate.

In March a guest slips on untreated ice at the second cabin. That resolves at $180,000.

In June a guest is injured on a dock at the fourth cabin. That resolves at $240,000.

In August a hot tub incident at the third cabin involves two guests and the combined exposure comes to $1.3 million. The aggregate has $1.58 million left at that point, so the money is there. The per occurrence limit is not. Payment caps at a million, and the owner covers the remaining $300,000.

Total paid for the year is $1.42 million. The aggregate has $580,000 left, and it is only September.

Two lessons sit inside that. The per occurrence limit binds first even when the aggregate is healthy. And a portfolio on one policy means one property’s bad year consumes the protection for all the others.

The endorsement portfolio owners should ask about

If you operate more than one property on a single liability policy, ask about a designated location general aggregate.

This endorsement gives each scheduled location its own aggregate rather than pooling them. A claim at the lake cabin stops eroding the protection at the mountain cabin. On commercial forms it is a standard endorsement, commonly referenced as CG 25 04, though availability and naming vary by carrier.

For a growing portfolio this is one of the higher-value structural changes available, and it is rarely offered unless someone asks.

How the umbrella interacts

An umbrella attaches above the underlying per occurrence limit and carries its own aggregate.

The part owners miss is that umbrellas usually require the underlying limits to be maintained. If the underlying aggregate is exhausted mid-year, the umbrella can treat the underlying limit as still in place, which means the owner is responsible for that layer before the umbrella responds.

An exhausted aggregate does not just end the primary coverage. It can open a gap underneath the umbrella, which is its own subject.

The sublimits inside liability

Several liability coverages carry their own caps that have nothing to do with the per occurrence limit. Damage to premises rented to you. Medical expense per person. On lodging forms, assault and battery, animal liability, and communicable disease frequently carry separate and much smaller limits.

On many forms those payments still erode the general aggregate. Small limits, full erosion.

What to ask

Ask what the aggregate limit is, and whether anything has already eroded it this policy period. That second question is one most owners have never thought to ask mid-term.

Ask whether defense costs are inside or outside the limit, and get the answer in writing. On a program or surplus lines policy this matters more than the limit itself.

If you own more than one property on one policy, ask whether a per location aggregate is available and what it costs.

If you want a second set of eyes on the answers, start with a free Risk Score. Thirty checks across six risk domains, about eight minutes, no email required to see your results.

Keep reading

Related articles.

Liability

Occurrence Versus Claims-Made, and Why It Matters Which One You Have

Which policy responds to a claim that surfaces years after the injury.
Read article →
Liability

Umbrella Policies: What Has to Sit Underneath One for It to Work

An exhausted aggregate can open a gap underneath the umbrella.
Read article →
Coverage Gaps

Policy Limits Versus Sublimits, and Where the Small Numbers Hide

Liability carries its own caps, and they still erode the general aggregate.
Read article →