Threshold/Articles/Claims & Coverage
Claims & Coverage · November 2026 · 7 min read

Deductibles That Are Not a Number: Wind, Hail, and Named Storm Percentages

A percentage deductible is not a percentage of your loss. It is a percentage of your dwelling limit, and it grows every year on its own.

The deductible is the one number on a policy owners believe they understand. Twenty-five hundred dollars, five thousand, whatever it says. You pay that, the carrier pays the rest.

That holds for a flat deductible. Most properties in hail country, wind country, or anywhere coastal now carry at least one deductible that is not a flat number, and the arithmetic on those runs differently than people assume.

You probably have more than one

A policy can carry several deductibles at once. An all-other-perils deductible for the ordinary claims. A separate wind and hail deductible. A named storm or hurricane deductible on top of that. Earthquake, where it applies. Increasingly a separate water damage deductible, and on some policies a separate roof deductible.

They do not stack on a single event. One applies per occurrence. Which one applies gets decided by the cause of loss, and that determination is the carrier’s to make first.

The practical consequence is that owners reserve for the smallest deductible on the page while carrying exposure to the largest one.

What the percentage is a percentage of

This is the part that surprises people, so it is worth stating flatly.

On residential and dwelling forms, a percentage deductible is almost always calculated against Coverage A, the dwelling limit. It has nothing to do with the size of the loss.

Commercial forms vary more. The percentage can apply to the limit for the affected coverage, to the value of the damaged property, or in some cases to the total insured value across all coverages. Those produce meaningfully different numbers on the same claim.

So the first question on any percentage deductible is not what percent. It is a percent of what.

Three claims on one property

A cabin with a $700,000 dwelling limit. All-other-perils deductible of $2,500. Wind and hail at two percent, which is $14,000. Named storm at five percent, which is $35,000.

A kitchen fire does $40,000. Fire is an all-other-perils loss. The deductible is $2,500 and the check is $37,500. This is the claim everyone pictures.

Hail damages the roof and the north siding, $46,000. Now the two percent applies. The owner absorbs $14,000 and receives $32,000. Roughly thirty percent of the loss came out of pocket.

A named storm does $120,000. Five percent applies. The owner absorbs $35,000 and receives $85,000.

Then the version that actually decides whether the coverage is useful.

A smaller hail event does $16,000. The deductible is still $14,000. The check is $2,000. For the most common storm loss in a hail market, this property is effectively uninsured.

That last scenario is not unusual. It is the typical hail claim in most of the Midwest and the mountain west, and it is the one owners never model.

The deductible rises every year and nobody tells you

Here is the part that connects to the dwelling limit problem.

A percentage deductible is tied to the dwelling limit. Inflation guard raises the dwelling limit annually. Which means the deductible rises annually too, automatically, without a conversation.

Take a $450,000 limit with a two percent wind and hail deductible. That is $9,000 of exposure. Run inflation guard at four percent for seven years and the limit reaches about $592,000. The deductible is now roughly $11,840.

The owner’s out-of-pocket exposure on a hail claim grew by about $2,800 and no document ever announced it. The declarations page showed a rising dwelling limit, which reads as good news, and the deductible line still said two percent.

Every year the coverage looks stronger and the retention gets larger.

Read the trigger, not just the number

Named storm and hurricane deductibles come with trigger language, and the trigger decides which deductible applies to a given event.

A named storm deductible typically attaches from the moment a storm is named by the National Hurricane Center and stays attached until some period after watches and warnings are discontinued, often between twenty-four and seventy-two hours. Damage inside that window gets the high deductible even when the wind at your property was unremarkable.

Hurricane deductibles sometimes attach only at a stated storm category or on landfall. Wind and hail deductibles usually have no time trigger at all and simply follow the cause of loss.

The percentage on the declarations page is half the information. The trigger is the other half and it lives in the endorsement.

Business income has a deductible measured in time

Worth knowing for anyone whose property earns nightly.

Income coverage frequently does not carry a dollar deductible. It carries a waiting period, commonly seventy-two hours, before coverage begins. Lost revenue during that window is yours.

So on a storm claim you are absorbing two retentions at once. A percentage deductible on the building and a waiting period on the income. Those are separate mechanisms and they run simultaneously.

Why carriers use them at all

Percentage deductibles push the frequent layer of catastrophic perils back onto the owner in markets where those perils drive the results.

In hail-prone and coastal markets, this is often the price of getting a policy at all. Carriers that cannot manage that exposure stop writing, and owners in those markets have watched that happen. A high wind deductible on an available policy beats a low deductible on a policy nobody will sell you.

The problem is not that the deductible exists. It is that owners find out what it equals in dollars during a claim.

What to do about it

Convert every percentage to a dollar figure and write those numbers somewhere you will see them. Not in your head.

Then set reserves against the largest one rather than the smallest. Most owners hold cash against a $2,500 deductible while carrying $35,000 of real retention.

Run the buy-down math before assuming a lower deductible is better. Ask what the premium difference is between two percent and one percent, multiply by five years, and compare it to the $7,000 of deductible you would be buying. Sometimes it is worth it and sometimes it is not, and the arithmetic is a two-minute job.

And know that deductibles apply per occurrence rather than per season. Two named storms in one year means two deductibles.

What to ask

Ask what each deductible on the policy equals in dollars today, and make the person quoting it do the multiplication out loud.

Ask what the percentage is calculated against. Coverage A, the affected coverage, or total insured value. The answer changes the number.

Ask what triggers the named storm deductible and how long it stays attached after a storm passes. That answer is in an endorsement rather than on the declarations page.

If you want a second set of eyes on the answers, start with a free Risk Score. Thirty checks across six risk domains, about eight minutes, no email required to see your results.

Keep reading

Related articles.

Operational Risk

Why the Dwelling Limit You Set in 2019 Is Wrong Now

The limit the percentage runs against, and why it drifts out of date.
Read article →
Coverage Gaps

The Deductible You Haven’t Done the Math On

The shorter coastal version: what a named-storm percentage costs on the claim most likely to come.
Read article →
Audit Guide

How to Read a Declarations Page, Line by Line

Where the deductibles are printed, and what the page does not tell you.
Read article →